Engaging with the Buddha – 1 April 2011 Q&A with Geshe Tenzin Zopa on the screening of the documentary “Decoding the Past” on the subject of Death-Bardo-Rebirth
1. After death and during the bardo (the intermeditate state between death and rebirth), does the consciousness choose its own future parents or does it depend on karma?
Ans: For most ordinary people, it will depend on their karma; but for those practitioners who can control their emotions and minds, they will be able to direct themselves towards their future parents while in the bardo.
2. How does powa work? Do we perform this when person passes away?
Ans: In Tibetan Buddhism, there is a practice called powa, where the dying person is assisted through meditation and prayer to a higher rebirth including the Purelands. The best time to do powa is after clinical death (when the gross body ceases) and before spiritual death (when the consciousness departs the body). When a dying person is no longer breathing and all the organs have shut down but yet, there is still some warmth at the spot below middle of chest and no fluids have as yet been discharged from nose or secret parts, this indicates clinical death but not spiritual death (i.e. the consciousness has not yet left the body) – that is the best time to do powa. There are various powa practices which come from the Tantric teachings – e.g. powa in relation to Amitabha Buddha or powa in relation to a Highest Yoga Tantra Buddha-deity like Vajryogini, Yamantaka, etc.. Commissioning the recitation of texts like the Tibetan Book of the Dead (Bardo Thodol) is also a form of powa practice. If one doesn’t get the chance to perform powa at the ideal time, powa can be done during bardo period. If that’s not possible, then doing so after 49 days can still be done but it will not be as effective as when done during the period between clinical death and spiritual death. Through the dedication of merit of such powerful practices, it can benefit the dec’d in the bardo state or even if the dec’d has been reborn, the conditions of wherever the person has been reborn can be improved.
3. If there is no Buddhist master around to do powa, how can we help?
Ans: To perform powa, one requires an initiation from a master who has high realisations on such practices; one should then do retreats in relation to the practice and to be of benefit to the dec’d, the person doing the powa practice should have some level of realisation (at least stable compassion). However, just dedicating one’s prayers –Chenresig Mantra, Medicine Buddha mantra etc... can be of great benefit to the dec’d because prayer dedications influence the mental imprints of the dec’d person.
4. According to the documentary, the Bardo has several stages – from seeing peaceful deities to wrathful deities. Where does throwing karma come in?
Ans: Throwing karma refers to where one is reborn – whether in the suffering lower realms and or in the higher realms. The first stage of the bardo is where the bardo being is influenced by hallucinations based on desire (hence, that consciousness tends to see peaceful yet desirous images). If one gets attached to such images, one’s desire will be enhanced and this will create another formation of karma – so if the dead person was supposed to take rebirth as human being but during bardo was strongly distracted by attachment, it could divert his rebirth into a preta being (a grasping suffering existence). So what one should do when encountering desirous images is that one should tell oneself that these images are mere objects of illusion, so there is no reason to be attached to the images. Instead, think that those images are Guru Vajrasattva or Guru Heruka with Vajrayogini. One can see from this that if one has stable practice in Highest Yoga Tantra, that will help one to perceive the Buddha mother-father deities rather than see ordinary desirous beings – and this could change your rebirth from ordinary human rebirth but into a Pureland rebirth. As for wrathful deities, those images can be quite scary and might trigger fear and agitation in one’s consciousness, which again could affect the realm of rebirth. Through being familiar with Buddhist wrathful deities, one understands that such wrathful images are to subdue negative emotions and not to harm oneself – in this way, when one encounters such images, one’s fear and anger can be transformed into a positive mind. Further, one will see many colours in the bardo state but by understanding emptiness, one realises that all are illusions and this brings the excited or fearful mind back into a calm state and use that calm-mind as a basis for virtuous thoughts and if one is unable to do that, one will at least by hearing prayers being recited, remember the Dharma and this will be a positive influence on one’s future rebirth. This illustrates that while we are alive, we should practice Dharma ourselves and not only rely on family members to help us with that. The Bardo Thodol explains that Yama (Lord of Death) is also a mere hallucination and there is no actual being there to take your life and cause you to suffer. By hearing prayers, the hallucinated mind of the bardo-being will disappear and when that happens, Yama, fear, suffering disappears. The conclusion is that everything is dependent on one’s mind. In terms of the type of prayers to be recited, it will depend on the individual – Buddhist masters often advise to recite the prayer that the dec’d person is most familiar with – e.g. if that person was familiar with Amitabha Buddha prayers, then recite prayers related to Amitabha for him/her. Generally, what is recommended are the 8 great Prayers (which includes the King of Prayers); Prayers related to Maitreya’s Dedications; Shantideva’s Dedication Prayer from the Dedication Chapter of Bodhicaryavatara, Maitreya Buddha’s mantra. Any sutras.
5. Kyabe Lama Zopa Rinpoche advises us to teach children about death. How do we do this for other family members?
Ans: It is a very challenging task. Some people think it is inauspicious to talk about death and some people have strong grasping to death or simply deny death and are thus unwilling to listen/discuss this subject matter. Rinpoche’s teachings constantly remind us about impermanence and death; the Buddha’s first teaching was about impermanence and death and it was his last teaching as well and in-between, this subject was frequently raised. The reason for it is for us to understand well and be fully prepared to overcome death.
6. For people who follow other/different religions, do they experience the bardo too?
Ans: Everyone (any samsaric being) will experience the bardo and its stages but the intensity of the images will depend on the imprints in that person’s mind. If the person had more negative imprints, the fearful quality of the images will be heavier; if the person had more virtuous imprints, the fearful experiences will be lighter. For the successful practitioners, they too go through the stages but they won’t see the images as frightening nor disturbing but feel joy instead. For non-Buddhists, they might have different explanations about death, based on their own understanding and philosophy. Some don’t even believe in rebirth or the bardo. What the Buddha and the realised beings saw was the death process as what was shown here. We need to think and choose a source that is reliable – for us, we choose what the Buddha described as his experience.
7. It was mentioned in the documentary that it is good to be born human because due to the suffering experienced, we will learn from it. Is it better to be born human or in Purelands?
Ans: The best is to be enlightened before death comes; next best is to be born in the Purelands to continue/complete one’s Dharma cultivation; next is the precious human rebirth where one can also continue/complete one’s Dharma cultivation.
8. Is Pureland in 6 realms?
Ans: Pureland is above (and outside) the 6 realms but it is not necessarily an enlightened state, as there are ordinary beings of great virtue who created causes to be born there but they still need to complete their training.
9. If a deceased person is not guided by any prayers and enters into the bardo state and encounters Yama, what happens?
Ans: Even if there were no prayers recited for such a person, if that person had cultivated during his/her lifetime, that cultivation will be the best form of guidance to the consciousness in the bardo. Of course, if one did not practice at all and there are no prayers recited for him/her, then there is the danger of being born in the lower realms. It is not necessary for all deceased beings to encounter Yama. It depends on one’s karma and mental imprints. (See above Answer to Q6)
10. Bardo period is said to last for a max. of 49 days (7x of 7 days periods) . Are these bardo stages “tests”?
Ans: In the bardo, one is meeting the result (of one’s karma); the “test” was during one’s life! If one had good practice during life, the difficulties in the bardo will be overcome. All images will be seen and understood as mere hallucinations. Not everyone has to experience those images in the bardo. For the great practitioners, instead of seeing peaceful and wrathful deities, the entire bardo experience is a wonderful, grand procession of dakas and dakinis (“angel”- like beings). In terms of speeding up rebirth, if one has very heavy negative karma, the bardo experiences become very intense and there would be no need to wait for 49 days – the images can appear right after death and the bardo-being (the consciousness of the deceased person) then enters the hell realm very quickly.
11. Just before my grandmother passed away, she saw holy beings coming and music. What does this mean?
Ans: That sounds like a good sign because if at the time of death, one has images of Buddhas, holy beings, it shows the consciousness has positive imprints and will thus have a positive bardo experience and a possibility of high rebirth. Although all images at death time are hallucinations, such images helps to bring the mind into calm and virtue and thus activates past good karmic imprints and this increases the chance of a good rebirth.
12. Is it true that everyone who has the chance to come here means that they have good karma from the past and also have the chance to be enlightened. For newcomers here, what kind of practice must they do?
Ans: As long as one wishes to be free from the samsaric world and gain enlightenment, one has to practice the 3 principal aspects of the path namely renunciation, bodhicitta and wisdom realising emptiness.
13. It is said that one needs to chant Amitabha prayer 10x before dying; sometimes someone at point of dying remembers the Amitabha prayer once.
Ans: Yes but one needs a strong foundation to even remember that prayer once. Without cultivation, just reciting mantra would not be enough. Otherwise, Buddha wouldn’t have given 84k teachings, he would have just given one mantra. To be born in Pureland, also not easy. The 3 principal aspects of the path.
14. My loved ones are not Buddhists but Christians – what can I do to help them when they pass away ?
Ans: There is no need to chant Buddhist prayers at that time. As one is interdependent with sentient beings, one should engage in virtues and dedicate it to them.
15. In the documentary shown, if one has more negative karma than positive karma at death-time, can one still obtain a precious human rebirth?
Ans: Yes, on one condition – if one can strengthen one’s past virtuous imprints through your own remembrance of virtue at that time or obtain the family’s help in helping you remember virtue. Doing so, it doesn’t mean all of one’s negative karma will be purified but it will create conducive conditions for you to gain a higher rebirth.
16. How does practice of Highest Yoga Tantra (HYT) benefit us at bardo stage?
Ans: HYT has most detailed and profound teaching on the 3 bodies of the Buddha (the 3 kayas). Dharmakaya (Buddha’s wisdom) practice is the most effective in overcoming conventional/relative death; sambogakaya (Buddha’s form visible to only bodhisattvas) practice is the most elaborate practice to overcome conventional/relative intermediate state and actualise higher rebirth or even enlightenment. Nirmanakaya (Buddha’s form visible to ordinary beings) practice serves sentient beings directly. The 3 kayas practice can be used at death time. But this can only be done if one has a firm understanding of the 3 principal aspects of the path and strong guru devotion. One can engage in the causal stage of enlightenment (through self-generation practice) and by remaining in that concentration of divine pride, by focusing all thoughts on the mandala and the deities therein, there will not be even one single space for hallucination or negative emotions to attack oneself. Due to this sustained practice, one will be able to secure one’s rebirth in the higher realms or even attain the enlightened state itself. The Guruyoga practice of seeing oneself, one’s Guru and the Buddha-deity (yidam) as inseparable, is one of the most forceful powa, to transfer consciousness from this suffering state into the enlightenment state. However, many senior practitioners find the meditation on 3 kayas quite challenging as death approaches because one’s body is weakened at that time and the gross mind is declining, making it difficult to remember fine details. Hence for some practitioners, visualising the self, Guru and Yidam as one, is an easier method to use as one approaches death. Once, I met a very senior monk from Tsum - who was over 80 years old and who had a great understanding of Lam Rim and Vajrayogini practices. I visited him as he was dying and he shared his experience of the difficulty of meditating on the 3 kayas due to his physical weakness, which was somehow affecting his energy and ability to remember all aspects of the practice and thus he felt quite disappointed. So I shared with him the advice that Geshe Lama Konchog (GLK) had told a elder monk at Kopan, Geshe Kechog. This old Geshe asked GLK how to condense one’s Dharma/meditative practices when one approaches death and was physically and mentally very weak. GLK advised, “Keep your mind, your Guru’s mind and Yidam’s mind in a state of oneness”. If one is not convinced about HYT practice or that it is too difficult, then one can close one’s eyes and think that whatever light sense in the eye is in fact the fused/joined state of one’s mind with that of one’s Guru and Yidam as one; then as one gets weaker, transfer your mind with the thought that one is already in the enlightenment state. Summary - 1. Familiarise yourself with the thought that oneself, one’s Guru and Buddha-deity are in oneness (if you haven’t taken any HYT initiation, then just visualise oneself as being one with one’s Guru). 2. Think of the light as one’s fused state (oneself, Guru, Buddha as one) 3. Tell yourself that you’re already in the enlightened state (of omniscience, purity and virtue) The above practice is from the HYT tantra. Kriya tantra and Performance tantra don’t have this practice.
17. If a person dies in an accident or disasters or through sudden death or in sleep, how will that person be able to generate a virtuous thought as the last thought?
Ans: It might be difficult although still possible. Those situations are not an ideal way to die. Death in conditions of shock can sometimes cause the person to be born as a spirit (preta realm) but if the person is well-practiced, then a good rebirth is still possible e.g. some Lamas die in accidents but due to their level of practice, they still gain higher rebirths. If one dies with much pain, attachment or anger towards one’s own body or others, it will be difficult to obtain a good rebirth; if one dies without thought at all, it will be a waste because death-time can be a good opportunity to practice and use it to gain a higher rebirth. The End of Q&A **Transcripts of each Engaging with the Buddha session are available on LDC’s website
www.fpmt-ldc.org